1958 Doubled Die Penny Value & Identification Guide
The variety is often searched for as the “1958 double die penny,” but the standard numismatic term is 1958 Doubled Die Obverse, or DDO. FS-101 is one of the rarest Lincoln Wheat Cent varieties, with three confirmed examples currently known.
Reviewed by the Coins Identification editorial team · Updated

How Much Is a 1958 Doubled Die Penny Worth?
Authenticity comes before price.
There is no normal value ladder for this variety. PCGS and NGC currently describe only three confirmed examples, so the market is driven by the exact authenticated specimen, its grade and color, provenance and auction competition.
The finest-known PCGS MS65 RD example realized $1,136,250, including buyer’s premium, at GreatCollections on January 22, 2023. The $336,000 Stack’s Bowers MS64 RD sale in March 2018 remains a separate historical result. Neither prices an unverified find.
Known 1958 Doubled Die Examples
Three confirmed specimens are currently described.
| Specimen / provenance | Grade / color | Certification | Public sale evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stewart Blay Collection | MS65 RD | PCGS · CAC | $1,136,250 · GreatCollections · Jan. 22, 2023 · lot 1272983 |
| ESM Collection | MS64 RD | PCGS | $336,000 · Stack’s Bowers · March 2018 · lot 2146 |
| Third confirmed specimen | MS64 RD | PCGS | Certified in 2006; no public auction recorded in the PCGS census |
PCGS condition census. No public transaction is listed for the third specimen, so no price is invented. Do not treat a provenance label as a new coin. One specimen can appear in more than one historical sale.

Did a 1958 Doubled Die Penny Really Sell for $336,000?
Yes. A PCGS-graded MS64RD 1958 Doubled Die Obverse FS-101 sold for $336,000 at Stack's Bowers in March 2018. The price reflects the tiny known population, dramatic doubling, original Red color, high grade and intense collector competition.
It does not mean every 1958 cent with a doubled-looking letter is valuable. Confirm the attribution, certification and individual lot first.

Original Stack’s Bowers lot 2146. This was a historical sale, surpassed by the MS65 RD example in 2023.
What Does a 1958 Doubled Die Penny Look Like?
Look for a coherent pattern across the obverse.
PCGS describes wide and pronounced doubling on LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST, with less pronounced doubling on the date, especially the 8. The pattern should match the known FS-101 diagnostics. A single blurry edge, scratch or flat shelf is not enough.
Compare broad separation across several letters.
Match the motto to the same attributed die.
Doubling is subtler, especially around the 8.
Open photographs of the confirmed PCGS specimens and obverse details. Generated illustrations explain locations and concepts; they are not exact die-matching plates.
Check LIBERTY
On the famous FS-101, LIBERTY shows broad, rounded separation across the letters. Compare the full word with an authoritative reference and check that the date and motto show the same die pattern.
Check IN GOD WE TRUST
The motto is another pronounced FS-101 diagnostic. Look for wide, rounded separation across multiple letters rather than a thin scratch or shelf-like edge. The motto should agree with LIBERTY and the date.
Check the 1958 Date
The date has less pronounced doubling than LIBERTY and the motto, with the 8 often providing the clearest place to look. Do not authenticate the variety from the date alone.
1958 Doubled Die vs Regular 1958 Penny
| Feature | Regular 1958 | 1958 DDO FS-101 |
|---|---|---|
| LIBERTY | Normal lettering | Strong rounded doubling |
| IN GOD WE TRUST | Normal lettering | Strong rounded doubling |
| Date | Normal | Less pronounced doubling, especially 8 |
| Mint mark | None on Philadelphia | None on Philadelphia |
| Rarity | Common issue | Three confirmed examples |
| Attribution | Regular cent | FS-101 / DDO-001 |

1958 Doubled Die vs Machine Doubling
A genuine doubled die is formed during die-making and creates rounded, separated design elements. Machine doubling occurs during the strike and usually appears flat, pushed or shelf-like. It does not create the same collector premium.

How Rare Is the 1958 Doubled Die Penny?
Three confirmed examples are currently known. PCGS and NGC describe one MS65RD and two MS64RD specimens. That is a known population, not a claim that no other genuine coin can ever be discovered.

When Was the 1958 Doubled Die Discovered?
The precise find date is uncertain. The current PCGS account places Charles Ludovico’s discovery around 1960 and cites a January 1966 Coin World report. Older references emphasize 1983–1984. These are different historical accounts; the early 1980s should not be presented as an uncontested first discovery date.
Does the 1958 Doubled Die Have a Mint Mark?
No. The famous FS-101 is a Philadelphia cent, so no mint mark below the date is correct. Do not call the absence of a letter a missing-mint-mark error.

Is There a 1958-D Doubled Die Penny?
The famous ultra-rare 1958 DDO FS-101 is a Philadelphia cent with no mint mark, not a 1958-D. Denver has separate RPM and other variety attributions, including documented RPM listings, but they are not the three-known FS-101. Do not use FS-101 prices for a Denver coin.

Why Is the 1958 Doubled Die So Valuable?
Extreme rarity, dramatic doubling, original Red color, high grade, certification, Lincoln cent demand and very few market opportunities all matter. A buyer is competing for one of only a few known coins, not for a normal date-and-mint cent.

1958 Doubled Die Penny Auction History
Historical results are not an average price.
| Date | Grade / color | Reported result | Evidence / context |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | MS64 RD | $25,025 | PCGS historical report · alternative grading holder |
| 2000 | MS64 RD | $57,500 | Same specimen as 1996, crossed to PCGS |
| March 2018 | MS64 RD | $336,000 | ESM Collection · Stack’s Bowers · lot 2146 |
| January 22, 2023 | MS65 RD | $1,136,250 | Stewart Blay Collection · GreatCollections · lot 1272983 · includes buyer’s premium |
PCGS documents the linked 1996 and 2000 appearances; GreatCollections lot 1272983 documents the 2023 sale. Some historical sales can involve the same specimen. They should not be counted as three different coins or treated as an average market price.
How to Authenticate a 1958 Doubled Die Penny
Check for no mint mark, strong LIBERTY doubling, strong motto doubling, the less pronounced date doubling, correct bronze specifications and known die diagnostics. A plausible discovery should go to a professional grading service. One photograph never proves authenticity.

Why Most “1958 Doubled Die” Finds Are Not FS-101
Machine doubling, die deterioration, damage, lighting, image blur, normal lettering and confusion with 1958-D can all create a false positive. Compare the shape and position of separation across multiple design areas without dismissing a coin before it is examined.

How Was the 1958 Doubled Die Created?
A doubled die begins with a doubled design on the working die, caused by a misaligned hub impression during die production. Coins struck afterward receive that doubled design. The coin was not simply struck twice.

Can You Buy a 1958 Doubled Die Penny?
Public market appearances are extremely rare because only three confirmed examples are currently known. Any raw “1958 DDO” listing deserves caution. An asking price does not establish authenticity, and a photo cannot verify the known diagnostics. Prefer a coin with a verifiable certification, provenance and matching FS-101 attribution.
1958 Doubled Die Penny Specifications
Do Not Clean a Possible 1958 DDO
Cleaning can remove original surfaces, create hairlines and obscure the diagnostic areas. Handle the coin by the edge, keep it dry and submit a valuable candidate for professional review.
1958 Doubled Die Penny FAQ
What is a 1958 Doubled Die Penny?
The famous variety is the Philadelphia 1958 Doubled Die Obverse, FS-101, also called DDO-001.
How much is a 1958 Doubled Die Penny worth?
The PCGS MS65 RD Stewart Blay specimen sold for $1,136,250 including buyer’s premium at GreatCollections on January 22, 2023. A different MS64 RD specimen sold for $336,000 in 2018. These are individual sales, not a grade-by-grade appraisal of an unverified coin.
Did a 1958 Doubled Die really sell for $336,000?
Yes. A PCGS MS64RD example sold at Stack's Bowers in March 2018. That result belongs to one specific coin.
What does a genuine 1958 Doubled Die look like?
Strong, rounded doubling is most apparent on LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST, with less pronounced doubling on the date, especially the 8.
How many 1958 Doubled Die Pennies are known?
PCGS and NGC currently describe three confirmed examples: one MS65RD and two MS64RD.
Does the famous 1958 DDO have a mint mark?
No. FS-101 is a Philadelphia issue, so the absence of a mint mark is correct.
Is there a 1958-D Doubled Die Penny?
The famous FS-101 is not a 1958-D. Denver has separate RPM and other variety attributions that must be evaluated independently.
How is a doubled die different from machine doubling?
A doubled die is formed during die production and has rounded, separated design. Machine doubling occurs during the strike and is usually flatter and shelf-like.
How can I authenticate a possible 1958 DDO?
Compare all known diagnostics, check specifications and submit a plausible high-value candidate to a professional grading service.




